There was really just one little thing that really upset me during my time in Oaxaca. In one of my Spanish lessons there was an activity where we were with partners making orraciones or Q & A conversations using information listed on a handout. When it came time to read them out loud, I read our first sentence: "Quien hacer las tortas?" and the teacher ofcourse corrected me because I left out the "va" between Quien and hacer. This is all good and useful, but then she went on to say (in spanish, Spain Spanish with the thhhhhhh sounds) that when I leave out the va I sound like an Indio. She then proceeded to repeat the sentence in the same voice that people use in the U.S. when they structure sentences and words into racist crap like: "Chief likum go big huntum."
I couldn't believe what was happening. Worse though, was that I couldn't explain in Spanish that I was offended that she would say such a thing (she doesn't speak English), so when my face fell she just went on to explain further. After a little of the shock wore off I was able to ask her why she used the word Indio, if that was a joke to her, and basically that I was offended. She apologized... I switched classes... problem solved? As it becomes more and more popular to be less and less politically correct I am sure more (white) people will tell me that I am too easily offended by this sort of thing. Part of me tells myself I am too easily offended sometimes. I cannot accept that perspective. It saddens me that behavior like this is considered acceptable, especially in an atmosphere that I assumed to be more professional. For anyone who doesn't know, Indigena is the appropriate and favored term by indigenous people in Latin America, Indio is a term that comes with many negative connotations.
This was really nothing compared to the racist verbal assault I experienced in Arizona over the summer, but it reopened some of the same wounds.
You're not too easily offended. While PC-ness can be taken too far and must be considered carefully before embarking on it, you also have to consider that it's origins lie in not trying to senselessly hurt someone else's feelings. It's meant to be an institutionalized way of respecting people inherently. I wonder if you could trace the roots of PC-ness to the old Christian tradition of calling everyone "friend", whether you've just met them or not... with the thinking that if you are respectful and considerate of others, they will be respectful and considerate of you, and if they're not, at least you have shown them kindness.
So you handled it well. Blowing up (as I might've done) would've been the wrong way to handle it. Explaining as well as you could that that was an offensive thing to you, and changing classes was definitely a good way to go about dealing with it.
Because I don't know how to give a different about me for each blog separately...
GIRL GETS GREENER: A chronicle of my journey in gradually becoming more green.
NOMAD NOYES:I was awarded a travel scholarship and decided I needed some way to ensure that my mother (and anyone else for that matter) would be able to live vicariously through my journeys. I am a proud member of the Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation and am focusing my Bonderman Travel Fellowship adventures on exploring the affinity that I feel towards other Indigenous peoples and the struggle, survival, and ingenuity that brings First Peoples together. Traveled 07 - 08
1 comment:
You're not too easily offended. While PC-ness can be taken too far and must be considered carefully before embarking on it, you also have to consider that it's origins lie in not trying to senselessly hurt someone else's feelings. It's meant to be an institutionalized way of respecting people inherently. I wonder if you could trace the roots of PC-ness to the old Christian tradition of calling everyone "friend", whether you've just met them or not... with the thinking that if you are respectful and considerate of others, they will be respectful and considerate of you, and if they're not, at least you have shown them kindness.
So you handled it well. Blowing up (as I might've done) would've been the wrong way to handle it. Explaining as well as you could that that was an offensive thing to you, and changing classes was definitely a good way to go about dealing with it.
hugs to you, m'dear.
k.
Post a Comment